Review: The Sacrificial Man

The Sacrificial ManThe Sacrificial Man by British writer Ruth Dugdall is a dark, absorbing, satisfyingly twisted psychological thriller.

The second novel to feature probation officer Cate Austin, The Sacrificial Man sees Cate charged with preparing a pre-sentence report for Alice Mariani, who is convicted of assisted suicide after helping her lover David Jenkins die. The couple met online after David, assuming the pseudonym Smith, posted the ad, ‘Man seeks beautiful woman for the journey of a lifetime: Will you help me to die?’ Alice aka Robin not only helps him die, but agrees to his outlandish request for her to consume some of his flesh after the event.

Although there is no evidence David/Smith was ill, the case becomes a cause célèbre for enthanasia advocates. Cate’s job is to assess the case and recommend a sentence to the judge, requiring her to spend time with Alice as she seeks to better understand her motives and to determine whether she is a danger to herself or others.

The two woman are drawn in sharp juxtaposition. Cate is a divorcée with shared custody of a young daughter, dismissed by Alice as ‘so average: brown hair, pale skin, a worn winter coat flapping over a navy suit with a white shirt. Predictable.’ Alice by contrast is in her own words ‘beautiful, slim, clever’, an academic with a fondness for Keats and an MG Midget parked out front of her beautifully appointed home.

The psychological sparring match between the two women drives the narrative, together with flashbacks to the traumatic childhood that shaped Alice’s warped notions of love and loyalty. What propelled David/Smith into Alice’s arms is also conveyed through diary entries written in the months leading up to his death.

Dugdall is unusual in allowing her villains — or are they victims? — to outshine her hero. This is the case in both The Sacrificial Man and her earlier novel, The Woman Before Me. The Sacrificial Man might be marketed as a Cate Austin novel, but it is Alice Mariani’s story that grabs the reader by the throat and won’t let go. The reader spends more time in Alice’s head than anywhere else, which is both unsettling and engrossing.

Dugdall doesn’t save the twists only for the tail. I can’t comment on any without risking spoilers, except to say I admire the dexterity with which she pulled these off.

I had to read the ending twice to get my head around what happened, and I’m still ruminating on how I feel about it. There were a few details that jarred — like whether a knife used to excise someone’s flesh in an assisted suicide would be taken in as evidence — and some gory bits involving cannibalism.

But while The Sacrificial Man may put off your food, it’s also guaranteed to keep you up at night, as only the best crime thrillers will do.

The Sacrificial Man by Ruth Dugdall (2012) is published by Text.


About Angela Savage

Angela Savage is a Melbourne writer, who has lived and travelled extensively in Asia. She won the 2004 Victorian Premier’s Literary Award for an unpublished manuscript, and the 2011 Scarlet Stiletto Award short story award. Angela holds a PhD in Creative Writing and currently works as Director of Writers Victoria.
This entry was posted in Reviews & Interviews and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Review: The Sacrificial Man

  1. Margot Kinberg says:

    Angela – This does seem like one of those thrillers that gets under one’s skin and makes one think. Those are worth remembering. I’ve always been particularly interested too in villains (or are they?) who are depicted so that we understand, even sympathise with, the way they think. As I re-read your post I asked myself what kind of person would agree to help another die, and what makes people choose assisted suicide. It sounds as though Dugdall explores this issue too. Really interesting! Thanks for the thoughtful review.


    • angelasavage says:

      Dugdall does explore the issue of assisted suicide but her touch is deft as she doesn’t make this the theme of the book, and in fact complicates the issue in several ways, not least of all by having the ‘victim’ not apparently suffering from a terminal illness. I couldn’t tell what the author’s position is on this issue at the end of the book, and I respect that as a strength of the narrative, leaving the reader to make up their own mind.


  2. kathy d. says:

    Wow! This review packs a punch as does the book. I’m not sure if I want to read it as it really would go beyond my comfort zone and I’m not usually a fan of twisted psychological thrillers. However, the issue of assisted suicide is important. I’ve heard people say they would help a terminally ill cancer patient die if he/she were asked. A well-known journalist here helped her mother, who was terminally ill with breast cancer, die and wrote a book about it. It’s quite a moral dilemma to ponder, if one were asked to help a dying person. I’ve always though I could not do it, but would advocate for very strong pain medication, but I don’t know if the person was suffering unbearably.
    I think the European countries that are making euthenasia available at the ill person’s request are making a positive social advance.


    • angelasavage says:

      Thanks Kathy for your comments. I think it’s valuable when fiction contributes to conversations about controversial issues like assisted suicide, albeit in a way that’s not straightforward (see my comment above in response to Margot).


  3. kathy d. says:

    Ooh, ambiguity on social and moral issues. That is itself controversial among readers. Some want writers to make their positions clear, others don’t mind if they are ambiguities. I’ve seen long blog discussions on this topic.


What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s